Once celebrated as a refreshing and witty take on late-night political commentary, *Gutfeld!* now finds itself in the midst of a growing controversy.

At the center of this turmoil is Tyrus, the former professional wrestler turned political commentator, whose increasingly dominant and divisive presence on the show has sparked a wave of criticism from its once-loyal fanbase.

When it first aired, *Gutfeld!* captivated audiences with its relaxed format, sharp satire, and engaging panel discussions. Regular contributors like Emily Compagno and Dave Landau, alongside Tyrus, brought a dynamic energy that resonated with viewers.

However, recent shifts in the show’s tone, largely attributed to Tyrus, have disrupted this balance, leaving many fans disenchanted.

“I used to love *Gutfeld!* but now I can’t even get through five minutes,” lamented one disillusioned viewer—a sentiment echoed across social media.

Critics argue that Tyrus’s style has grown increasingly disruptive, with constant interruptions, lengthy monologues, and a tendency to dominate conversations. What was once seen as charismatic energy now feels overbearing, transforming the show’s atmosphere from lively and entertaining to tense and frustrating.

This shift has reportedly impacted the show’s ratings, particularly among the key 25-54 demographic. Media analyst Nancy Field noted, “Audiences can forgive a bad joke—but not being forced to sit through one person steamrolling everyone else.” With ratings showing early signs of decline, concerns about the show’s future have intensified.

Social media platforms have become battlegrounds for heated debates. While some fans defend Tyrus as a bold voice challenging mainstream narratives, others feel his presence overshadows the show’s original charm.

One Twitter user remarked, “Tyrus dropped a truth bomb on *The View*—but now it feels like he’s turning *Gutfeld!* into his personal soapbox.” Critics have been even harsher, accusing him of being aggressive and disrespectful. “He doesn’t let anyone finish a sentence,” complained one viewer, capturing the frustration of many.

Caught in the middle of this controversy is Greg Gutfeld, the show’s host and creative leader. Thus far, Gutfeld has remained silent, but the pressure to address the growing dissatisfaction is mounting. Fans are calling for changes, ranging from reducing Tyrus’s airtime to removing him from the panel entirely. The challenge for Gutfeld lies in balancing loyalty to his co-host with the demands of an increasingly disillusioned audience.

The controversy surrounding Tyrus goes beyond panel dynamics; it reflects a deeper debate about what *Gutfeld!* should represent. For some, Tyrus remains a vital voice, unafraid to challenge liberal narratives. For others, his dominance has eroded the show’s strengths—its wit, balanced discussions, and intelligent debate—replacing them with tension and discord.

The coming weeks will be critical for *Gutfeld!* as it navigates this crisis. Will Greg Gutfeld make changes to restore the show’s balance, or will he double down on Tyrus’s polarizing persona? The decisions made now will shape the program’s future and determine whether it can regain its former appeal—or if the damage is already irreversible.